The Brera is a complete failure, despite not being a BAD car. Right from the start everyone, even Alfa knew it's not going to be a success - at least they should have. The reason is that it was such an overweight car and the 4wd system has too much inertia. This is the unfortunate result of being forced to use the GM platform that was spawn the next Saab 900 as well.
The rest is now history. Fiat and GM fell out and when the Brera, 159 and Spider performance figures were publised GM knew they had a white elephant in this platform and ditched it (and Saab altogether).
This platform and the GM twin phaser engines (Brera/Spider/159 have GM blocks and Alfa heads) might be good for yank tanks but for a sporting brand like Alfa they are off pace!
The Brera with those looks should have been as Giugiaro designed it, i. e. RWD and the Maserati V8. It would have sold in low volumes but the image and credibility of the brand would not have been affected.
On the other hand, the image of Alfa has suffered so much over the years thanks to poor marketing management that car jurnos expect a flawless car from the brand or else they bash it.
For example the 159 is not overweight when compared with it's rivals from the class. Look at the C-Class and Lexuse IS!!!! However no road test has called them heavy! Only the 3 series is considerably lighter. And now with the new 1.8T 200BHP engine the 159 is very competitive car in the sector.
Supra I'll go for the GT with the Arese V6!