Proton Or Tata

[ImshiK]

Guys,

I have a budget of nearly 1.1 mil and wanted to buy a decent car which i wanted to give it out for rent service as well ...

I have thought about TATA INDIGO/INDICA and PROTON WIRA.

But I have doubts whether these vehicles would help me for the long run and resale as well

Please advice

[harshansenadhir]

Guys,

I have a budget of nearly 1.1 mil and wanted to buy a decent car which i wanted to give it out for rent service as well ...

I have thought about TATA INDIGO/INDICA and PROTON WIRA.

But I have doubts whether these vehicles would help me for the long run and resale as well

Please advice

with both of the options, you have to forget the resale value. However, if you're considering to give it for rent a car purpose, then the tata might do with cheap spares. On the other hand proton might run with mitsu spares but body parts like lights may be difficult to source compared to tata. After about 3 years nothing much would left in tata interior as plastics they used are prone to break very easily and looks horrible after sometime.

[chami11]

DON'T EVEN THINK ABOUT TATA INDIGO... Protone Wira is far better than Tata. My neighboring lady doctor bought a brand new Indigo & it started to give plenty of problems just before 2 years

[ImshiK]

thanx a lot for the reply guys

Do u think Hyundai accent would be good for this or a mazda, mitsubishi, nissan which i could afford for my budget would be profitable?? but my doubts are whether the cabs service would accept vehicles which is not English number plated

[harshansenadhir]

thanx a lot for the reply guys

Do u think Hyundai accent would be good for this or a mazda, mitsubishi, nissan which i could afford for my budget would be profitable?? but my doubts are whether the cabs service would accept vehicles which is not English number plated

accent or a soluna would do i guess.

[ImshiK]

Soluna is good but a second hand is abt 1.3 mil isnt it???

[Rohnd]

Guys,

I have a budget of nearly 1.1 mil and wanted to buy a decent car which i wanted to give it out for rent service as well ...

I have thought about TATA INDIGO/INDICA and PROTON WIRA.

But I have doubts whether these vehicles would help me for the long run and resale as well

Please advice

Proton Wira Should be the choice in terms of realiability.

[harshansenadhir]

Soluna is good but a second hand is abt 1.3 mil isnt it???

yes, somewhere around that. Stretching a bit would always save you some money in the future. If you can stretch to 1.3 then fb14 too would be an option.

[ImshiK]

Thnks a lot guys...